The High School Male Team of the Year Award dates back to 1968. Prior to then, the Male Team of the Year was awarded to the top team among all levels of competition.
| Year | Team |
|---|---|
| 2025 | New Rockford-Sheyenne-Maddock Football |
| 2024 | Bismarck High Track and Field |
| 2023 | Thompson Baseball |
| 2022 | Four Winds-Minnewaukan Basketball |
| 2021 | Langdon-Edmore-Munich Football |
| 2020 | Langdon-Edmore-Munich Football |
| 2019 | Jamestown Basketball |
| 2018 | Hillsboro-Central Valley Basketball |
| 2017 (tie) |
Grand Forks Central Hockey |
| Minot Basketball | |
| 2016 | Grand Forks Red River Hockey |
| 2015 | Minot High Hockey |
| 2014 | Cavalier Football |
| 2013 | Bismarck Football |
| 2012 | Beulah Basketball |
| 2011 | North Star Basketball |
| 2010 | Bismarck Cross Country |
| 2009 | Hillsboro Football |
| 2008 | Fargo South Football |
| 2007 | Napoleon Wrestling |
| 2006 | Bismarck Track |
| 2005 | New Rockford-Sheyenne Basketball |
| 2004 | West Fargo Football |
| 2003 | Dickinson Basketball |
| 2002 | Dickinson Trinity Football |
| 2001 | Dickinson Trinity Football |
| 2000 | West Fargo Football |
| 1999 (tie) |
Leeds Basketball |
| Watford City Football | |
| 1998 | Dickinson Track |
| 1997 | New England-Regent Football |
| 1996 | Killdeer Football |
| 1995 | Bismarck Century Wrestling |
| 1994 | Minot Ryan Basketball |
| 1993 | Central Valley Basketball |
| 1992 | Bismarck Wrestling |
| 1991 | Watford City Basketball |
| 1990 | Beulah Football |
| 1989 | Fargo South Football |
| 1988 | Bismarck Century Wrestling |
| 1987 | Fargo South Track |
| 1986 | Watford City Football |
| 1985 | Williston Wrestling |
| 1984 | Linton Basketball |
| 1983 | Hettinger Basketball |
| 1982 | Fargo North Hockey |
| 1981 | Bismarck Wrestling |
| 1980 | Dickinson Trinity Football |
| 1979 | Fargo South Football |
| 1978 | Minot Track |
| 1977 | Epping Basketball |
| 1976 | Fargo Shanley Football |
| 1975 | Bismarck Wrestling |
| 1974 | Grand Forks Central Basketball |
| 1973 | Fargo Shanley Football |
| 1972 | Bismarck St. Mary's Basketball |
| 1971 | Bismarck Track and Field |
| 1970 | Grand Forks Central Basketball |
| 1969 | Grand Forks Central Hockey |
| 1968 | Fargo Shanley High School Football |